Re: oke
Posted: October 4th, 2017, 2:02 pm
So first of all, we need to sort the 3def rule out, I’d recommend everyone in Haxball to read and actually comprehend these rules (same as HCL, NC) : http://league1.org/viewtopic.php?f=91&p=77#p77
I know the FM rules are much more vague and easier to interpret however you want, which benefits a striker like Kivi, but it’s not of any real value for most of these offenses.
An obvious touch, not a big offense though.
The ball is inside the attacking zone and you intercepted it, 4def for sure in HCL, but because of the vague terms within the FM rulebook, you might get away with it (as the print you referred to earlier somewhere; rule 2.5)
You go below the dm (aka entering the attacking area) and block a potential cross, how can you even argue that this isn’t breaking the rules? (a minor one though aswell)
Same here.
The goalkeepers position doesn’t justify you staying inside the attacking zone.
I know the FM rules are much more vague and easier to interpret however you want, which benefits a striker like Kivi, but it’s not of any real value for most of these offenses.
Kivi wrote:0:27 I don't see a touch, I was on my back movement immediately after you did.
An obvious touch, not a big offense though.
The ball is inside the attacking zone and you intercepted it, 4def for sure in HCL, but because of the vague terms within the FM rulebook, you might get away with it (as the print you referred to earlier somewhere; rule 2.5)
Kivi wrote:1:16
Are you serious?
You go below the dm (aka entering the attacking area) and block a potential cross, how can you even argue that this isn’t breaking the rules? (a minor one though aswell)
Kivi wrote:1:23
?????
Same here.
The goalkeepers position doesn’t justify you staying inside the attacking zone.